THE INFLUENCE OF EXPERIENCE OF THE RUSSIAN-UKRAINIAN WAR AT SEA ON NAVAL THEORY OF NATO COUNTRIES

Authors

  • S. V. Kurdiuk Scientific and Research Center of the Armed Forces of Ukraine "State Oceanarium" of the Institute of Naval Forces of the National University "Odesa Maritime Academy" https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3165-4571
  • A. O. Fylypenko Scientific and Research Center of the Armed Forces of Ukraine "State Oceanarium" of the Institute of Naval Forces of the National University "Odesa Maritime Academy" https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8283-5313
  • A. A. Bondarenko Scientific and Research Center of the Armed Forces of Ukraine "State Oceanarium" of the Institute of Naval Forces of the National University "Odesa Maritime Academy" https://orcid.org/0009-0009-1965-7831

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.32782/msd/2025.1/10

Keywords:

The Russian-Ukrainian war, the Black Sea, unmanned surface vehicles, NATO

Abstract

The article analyzes the publications of experts from NATO member states – the United States, the United Kingdom, and Germany – on the lessons of the Russian-Ukrainian war at sea. It is found that the experience of combat operations in the Black Sea is carefully analyzed by Western researchers. Of particular interest is the use of unmanned maritime vehicles for various purposes by the Ukrainian Defense Forces. Experts point out that thanks to their use, Ukraine, which has virtually no fleet of its own, has managed to significantly limit the activity of the Russian fleet and ensure the functioning of a temporary trade route, the “Ukrainian grain corridor.” In their view, the Ukrainian experience can be useful for other countries that do not have significant budgets for the maintenance of a classical military fleet and need to improve their defense from the sea, including the Baltic states. In addition, maritime drones make warship supply systems vulnerable and threaten ports of embarkation, which in turn will affect the ability of naval forces to conduct more effective operations at sea. At the same time, most military experts from the world's leading countries believe that the experience of the Russian-Ukrainian war at sea is not universal and is due to the specifics of the geographical and operational situation in the Black Sea. There are certain restrictions on the use of unmanned maritime vehicles, which means that they cannot be a full-fledged replacement for classical warships.

References

Savitz S.& Courtney W. What are the takeaways from Ukraine’s fight in the Black Sea? DefenceNews. 30.10.2023. URL: https://www.defensenews.com/opinion/2023/10/30/what-are-the-takeaways-from-ukraines-fight-inthe-black-sea/ (Дата звернення: 04.01.2025)

Pili G. Sea drones at war: Tactical, operational and strategic analysis of maritime uncrewed systems. European Security & Defence. 05.09.2024. URL: https://euro-sd.com/2024/09/articles/40191/sea-drones-at-war-tactical-operational-and-strategic-analysis-of-maritime-uncrewed-systems/ (Дата звернення: 04.01.2025)

Kaushal S. Ukraine’s Uncrewed Raid on Sevastopol and the Future of War at Sea. RUSI. 02.02.2023. URL: https://rusi.org/explore-our-research/publications/commentary/ukraines-uncrewed-raid-sevastopol-and-future-war-sea (Дата звернення: 04.01.2025)

Kaushal S. Lessons for the Royal Navy’s Future Operations from the Black and Red Sea. RUSI. 26.07.2024. URL: https://rusi.org/explore-our-research/publications/commentary/lessons-royal-navys-future-operations-black-andred-sea

Kaushal S. Lessons from the Black and Red Sea on the Use and Design of Future Fleets. RUSI. 09.08.2024. URL: https://rusi.org/explore-our-research/publications/commentary/lessons-black-and-red-sea-use-and-design-futurefleets(Дата звернення: 04.01.2025)

Huminsky J. Learning the right lessons from Ukraine’s naval war. Engelsberg Ideas. 06.06.2024. URL: https://engelsbergideas.com/notebook/learning-the-right-lessons-from-ukraines-naval-war (Дата звернення: 07.01.2025)

Das Schwarze Meer: Schauplatz des asymmetrischen Seekriegs Im Interview: Dr. Sebastian Bruns, Wissenschaftler am Institut für Sicherheitspolitik an der Universität Kiel (ISPK). German Institute for Defence and Strategic Studies. 27.06.2024. URL: https://gids-hamburg.de/das-schwarze-meer-schauplatz-des-asymmetrischen-seekriegs/(Дата звернення: 07.01.2025)

Rahr Ch. Going Asymmetric: How Ukraine Is Keeping Russia at Bay in the Black Sea . The American Enterprise Institute. 25.05.2023. URL: https://www.aei.org/op-eds/going-asymmetric-how-ukraine-is-keeping-russia-at-bay-inthe-black-sea/ (Дата звернення: 08.01.2025)

Pettyjohn S. Evolution Not Revolution. Drone Warfare in Russia’s 2022 Invasion of Ukraine. Center for a New American Security. 08.02.2024. URL: https://www.cnas.org/publications/reports/evolution-not-revolution (Дата звернення: 08.01.2025)

Wills S. Sea Drone Swarms – Can NATO’s Navies Avoid Russia’s Fate? Center for European Policy Analysis. 06.04.2024. URL: https://cepa.org/article/sea-drone-swarms-can-nato-navies-avoid-russias-fate/ (Дата звернення: 08.01.2025)

Flint C. Bottled up in the Black Sea: Russia is having a dreadful naval war, hindering its great power ambitions. The Conversation. 03.10.2023. URL: https://theconversation.com/bottled-up-in-the-black-sea-russia-is-having-adreadful-naval-war-hindering-its-great-power-ambitions-238195 (Дата звернення: 08.01.2025)

Russel J.A. Ukraine challenges conventional wisdom of war on the high seas. Responsible Statecraft. 16.11.2023. URL: https://responsiblestatecraft.org/ukraine-war-navy/ (Дата звернення: 08.01.2025)

Published

2025-03-25

How to Cite

Курдюк, С. В., Филипенко, А. О., & Бондаренко, А. А. (2025). THE INFLUENCE OF EXPERIENCE OF THE RUSSIAN-UKRAINIAN WAR AT SEA ON NAVAL THEORY OF NATO COUNTRIES. Maritime Security and Defense, (1), 67-73. https://doi.org/10.32782/msd/2025.1/10